Issue 12 - It's a kind of Magic

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site, you are agreeing to our Cookie Policy.



  • Heyho fellow gamers!

    As promised, here is the BTS blog containing all the rules for the new magic phase. Sadly, due to several different reasons, it got delayed (it was mainly my (@Kathal) fault, so blame me and not the other guys), however, better late than never, right?

    We have divided the structure of this BTS blog into two parts. The first outlines the magic rules, while the second will deal with the Paths of Magic (expect around 6-10 days delay), since you HAVE TO READ the magic rules first before being able to understand the changes done to the Paths.

    Furthermore, as always, here is the official discussion (and also question) thread for this Issue: BTS Blog - Issue 12 Discussion Thread


    Lets kick of the blog with the most fundamental question: Why the changes to begin with?

    There are several reasons:
    • Variance in spell generation in 1.3 sometimes causes "FeelsBadMan" moments of wasting an investment when you do not roll usable spells
    • Variance in the Magic Dice generation. We all know those games when you never generate more than 6 power dice but the enemy is on a hot streak with 9+ every turn.
    • Fundamental flaws in different aspects, such as Bound Spells.
    • Variance in both casting as dispelling
    • Background-driven design (the background explanation can be found in the Full Magic Path document: link to the download) which renders the current system meaningless.
    • Legal considerations


    As we can already see, there are already a lot of different reasons why the teams wanted to change the magic phase. Simply said, the goal was:

    Design a fun, diverse and background driven magic phase, which lowers the randomness to the previous (1.3) magic phase while enabling all sorts of magic set-ups (from no magic investment to "high end" magic investment). Furthermore, it needs to be balanced.


    However, before kicking off with brainstorming internally, we asked EVERYONE to share their thoughts on the magic phase given the above guidelines. An astonishing 83 proposals were submitted and the respective teams read through every single one of them to get an impression of what players want. You can find them all here: Full Magic Phase Proposals

    While there were a lot of great suggestions and ideas in those proposals, it would have been impossible to implement all of them. That being said, several concepts for magic dice generation, Wizards "levels" and Bound Spellsfound their way into the Second Edition Magic Phase.

    So, without further ado, lets kick it off with the new magic phase:

    Wizards and Spell Generation



    Previously there were only 2 types of Wizards: the "Apprentice" and the "Master". Now, there is a third type of Wizard, the "Wizard Adept" which is somewhere in between the Apprentice and the Master. Each type has slightly different rules and also generates their spells in their own way. Also, just because there exist now three types of Wizards, does not mean that all armies will have access to all three types. Some armies might only have access to the "Apprentices" and "Masters", while others might not have an "Apprentice" option at all and instead have the "Adept". This depends on the background of the army.
    • "Wizard Apprentices" are the least powerful of the wizards. As a result, they are also the cheapest wizards to field. An Apprentice only has access to one spell.
    • "Wizard Adepts" are more versatile than "Apprentices", thanks to more spells. An Adept has access to two spells and has "Channel (1)"*
    • "Wizard Masters" are the most powerful and also experienced Wizards out there. This is both reflected in their flexibility as their cost. A Master has access to four spells, has "Channel (1)"* and grants a +1 casting bonus for spells.
    *"Channel" got completely reworked, it will get explained later on.

    As we can already see, both the casting as the dispelling bonus from Wizards for spells have been reduced. Only the Wizard Master grants a casting bonus of +1, and other two Wizard types none at all. The dispel bonus is completely gone. This evens out the magic defence for armies between low to no magic investment and high magic investment. Previously the "Aether Icon" and the "Crown of Scorn" were the band aid enabling some parity.

    As a direct compensation, the casting values of all spells went down.



    Spell Selection


    Icon of the Path of Shamanism

    The Spell selection was one of the most criticized points of the old Magic phase, since it typically resulted overinvestment into the magic phase just to have usable spells. The aim of the changes done here is to both reduce the randomness and to make different magic set-ups more appealing (so no default spamming of Wizard Masters).

    Second Edition WIP BRB wrote:

    Spell Selection


    Starting with the player that picked their Deployment Zone, each player must now choose spells for their Wizards, one at a time. All Magic Paths can be found in The 9th Age: Fantasy Battles - Paths of Magic. Hereditary* Spells can be found in each Army Book

    Wizard Apprentices
    • Know 1 spell
    • Can choose between the Learned Spell 1 of their chosen Path and the Hereditary* Spell of their army
    Wizard Adepts
    • Know 2 spells
    • Can choose between the Learned Spells 1,2,3, and 4 of their chosen path and the Hereditary* Spell of their army
    • Cannot choose both Learned Spell 1 and 4
    Wizard Master
    • Know 4 spells
    • Can choose between the Learned Spells 1,2,3,4,5 and 6 of their chosen Path and the Hereditary* Spell of their army
    • Cannot chose both Learned Spell 1 and 6

    *The Hereditary Spell is a unique, background designed spell for each army. Some ACS have already published their respective Hereditary Spell, so go check it out!


    No random spell generation anymore!

    However, as a trade off, one cannot have every combination of spells on a single Wizard. This results in a dynamic where two Adepts might reap more benefits than a simple Master due to their flexibility even though they do not offer a casting bonus. On the other hand, playing multiple Wizard Apprentices gives access to more "Dominant" items (aka old Arcane Artefacts) and it allows more crucial Hereditary spells (*looking at you Evocation of Souls*).

    As testing has shown, this results in a lot of different and very unique magic set-ups, from 1 Adept + 2 Apprentices to the lone standard Wizard Master. Every (usable) combination of magic set-ups has been tested and found to be good, or at least reasonable (4 Wizard Apprentices didn't really work though :sweat: ).

    HOWEVER:
    While you can have the same spell multiple times with different Wizards, to prevent spam, each spell can only be attempted to be cast once. Bound Spells, Attribute Spells and spells with "Replicable" (being able to cast it more than one time per turn) ignore this restriction.


    Now that we know what types of Wizard will exist and how they generate their spells, lets address how we generate magic dice.

    Flux Cards and "Siphoning the Veil"

    Flux Cards and "Siphoning the Veil"



    Previously, dice generation were randomized using dice. While a random factor is still in the new system, several steps have been taken to lessen it, making the phase overall more fair to both players and also enabling resource management by introducing a "storage system".

    In the 2.0 magic phase, instead of rolling dice to determine how many Magic Dice the players have available, there is a deck of 8 "Flux Cards". At the beginning of the magic phase, simply draw one randomised flux card from your deck. This card determines how the number of Magic Dice as well as Veil Tokens (a secondary magic resource) the players receive. Once a Flux Card has been drawn, it gets discarded and thus cannot be drawn again. Furthermore, the "Flux deck" is open information for both players. Hence, probability becomes a factor in the following turns.

    As mentioned previously, "Veil Tokens" are the second magic resource and also the "storage system", which interacts with "Siphon the Veil" and "Channel".

    Second Edition WIP BRB wrote:

    Siphoning the Veil

    The Active Player creates a new pool of Veil Tokens. The main sources are Flux Cards, models with Channel and Veil Tokens saved from the Active Player's previous Magic Phase.

    These Veil Tokens can now be turned into Magic Dice for a cost of 3:1 - 3 Veil Tokens for 1 Magic Dice. To do this the Active Player removes any number of Veil Tokens from their pool. For each full 3 Veil Tokens that were removed, the Active Player adds a Magic Dice to their Magic Dice Pool. Up to 4 Magic Dice may be added to the Active Player's pool this way.

    Afterwards, remove Veil Tokens in the pool until it contains no more than 3 tokens. The remaining Veil Tokens are saved to be added to the Veil Token pool in the Active Player's next Magic Phase.
    This means, that thanks to the rule "Channel" every Wizard excluding Wizard Apprentices generate X Veil Tokens to the amount of "Channel (X)" they have. In return, Veil Tokens can either be stored for the next Magic Phase or turned into Magic Dice.

    This enables different combinations of Wizards and potential Exotic Artefacts (aka Magic Items) reap a different benefits from the Veil Tokens. Some set-ups thrive with 4 or 7 Veil Tokens from the Flux Cards (for example with "Channel (2)" - 1 additional dice for those magic phases), others thrive with anything but 7.

    Furthermore, by being able to store up to three Veil Tokens a player can bank his/her magic phase this turn for a stronger magic phase next turn. However, players are still limited to 4 additional dice, which makes "Channel spam" and/or overloading on a single magic phase rather hard to do.

    This allows armies to design magic items or Racial Traits, which can interact directly with the Veil Tokens, by either changing the limit that can be stored or using it as a resource ("boosting" your spells with them).


    Overall, these changes make the magic phase more fair to both players while the storage system for Veil Tokens introduces more tactical depth.

    There was also a lot of talk about scalability of the magic phase. As everyone is aware, the current (1.3) magic phase is very poor in this regard. Several different proposals and ideas tried to address this exact issue, but the fundamental problems were always the same:
    a) They only worked in a specific point range flawlessly
    b) Created problems for the standard game size without being able to address those in any acceptable way
    c) Mostly were overly complicated without an overall net gain

    Hence, instead of trying to find THE perfect solution, which would work for every point value, a tailor-made solution for the normal game size (between 4000 and 5000pts) was chosen. Furthermore, as the respective teams hope to support both smaller as bigger games in the future with different supplement packs.


    After the Wizards, Spell Selection, Flux Cards and "Siphoning the Veil", there are two more key changes left, "Fizzle" and "Miscasts".

    "Fizzle" and "Miscast"

    Fizzle*


    *Name is still under WIP

    Fizzle is a brand new rule in the magic phase, which helps mitigate extreme bad luck for both players while not being a foolproof method to abuse.

    Second Edition WIP BRB wrote:

    Fizzle

    When a Casting or Dispel Attempt is failed, any Magic Dice that rolled a natural '1' are put back in the Magic-Dice Pool from which they came. This does not apply to Casting or Dispel Attempts that fail due to "Not Enough Power"*.

    Note that this does not apply to passed Casting Attempts that are then dispelled.
    *"Not enough power" means unsuccessful casting or dispelling attempts with only one die.

    This should minimize the "feels bad" moments of the magic phase, where a player got already punished by an bad roll. There is little to no need to punish one even harder for this.



    Similar to the rest of the magic phase, the old Miscast system was heavily criticised by players due to its harshness. Some armies like Elves suffered severely under "Witchfire", while armies like WDG with their ironclad bodies would just laugh about it. Furthermore, there were and still are discussions going on in the Public Forum if Miscast are even necessary.

    Looking at it from a background perspective (remember, we are doing background-driven design), the Immortal Realm, the source of all the Magic, is toxic for inhabitants of the Mortal Realm. However, the same can be said in the other direction. Hence, working with Magic, which is poisonous, is neither easy nor safe and thus Miscasts are something, which should get implemented into the game.

    After knowing that Miscasts should be implemented, the question was in which form. Again, a lot of different proposals got created and dismissed but in the end, the team settled on this version:


    The tl;dr version is basically:
    • No "Overwhelming Power" anymore, so we do not get an additional bonus when "Miscasting"
    • We miscast now when we roll three of the same and then check the table
    • Depending on how many dice are rolled the result either moves up or down the chart
    • We suffer one effect only


    This is basically the new magic phase. Though, there are some points left to explain:

    The Rest

    Bound Spells



    Similar to the other aspects of the Magic Phase, Bound Spells in their current form have multiple fundamental flaws. Being able to force through a bound spell risk free and also the option of spam (BH Totems) without a real drawback was an issue.

    In the Second Edition Magic Phase those problems got addressed and Bound Spells got reworked into this:
    • Bound Spells will have two Power Levels, which are given as values in brackets (for example: Sigil of Glory (4/8)*)
    • If we want to cast a Bound Spell, either discard 2 or 3 Magic Dice from your Magic Dice pool:
      • If we discard 2 Magic Dice, than the casting value is equal to the Bound Spells primary Power Level (in this case 4)
      • If we discard 3 Magic Dice, than the casting value is equal to the Bound Spells secondary Power Level (in this case 8)
    • The cast is always successful
    • Bound [lexicon]Spells[/lexicon] trigger [lexicon]Path Attribute[/lexicon] [lexicon]Spells[/lexicon]
    • Dispelling works the same as usual, the dispelling roll has to be at least equal to the casting value of the [lexicon]Bound Spell[/lexicon] (in this case either 4 or 8)
    *This is a new Exotic Item with a unique Bound Spell in the BRB

    These changes address the two most glaring issues mentioned above, since it removes the risk free "force through" by five dicing a bound spell and also weakens the spam of Bound Spells. However, at the same time, the Power Level can be adjusted freely. Basically there could be a Bound Spell with a relatively high primary value (6 for example) but a lower secondary value (7) which makes the primary casting value similar to a spell cast with 2 dices. Since Dwarven Holds are directly affected by this (their whole Magic Phase is Bound Spell based) it creates ways to balance their Magic Phase by either increasing or lowering the respective casting values.

    Furthermore, the previous dispelling bonus against Bound Spells (getting +1 by default) is gone due to this changes.


    "Remains in Play" Spells

    The last point is "Remains in Play" spells which have two problems: either they are great or useless. When the opponent also invests into a proper magic phase, they are great, cause either they draw Magic Dice when casting it or ruin the opponent's magic phase, since he is kinda forced to dispel it with his Magic Dice sooner than later. On the other hand, against armies with little to no magic investment, "Remains in Play" spells are completely wasted, since dispelling such a spell in the opponent's Magic Phase is free.

    After a lot of discussion it was decided, that removing "Remains in Play" spells from the game, would be the best going forward. There is only a single exception for this, which is "The Oaken Throne" from the Path of Druidism. Since the whole Path revolves around this particular "Remains in Play" spell, there was no other real solution to either keep it as it is or rework the complete Path. Since reworking a functioning and good Path was deemed unnecessary, the first solution has been taken.


    Besides those two, there are a boatload of other smaller changes to the Magic Phase, due to the new rules (most of them just rules updates). However, it wouldn't really make sense to spoiler those, when they are only wording, rules, or layout updates. Most importantly, Casting and Dispelling Spells is still the same.


    That's it for this time guys. If you have any questions, want to give feedback or just want to troll us ( ;) ), please use the official feedback thread for this issue: BTS Blog - Issue 12 Discussion Thread

    As always,

    Your BTS Blog Team!
    "When four Kings abdicate their thrones, do you really have a Kingdom anymore?"

    I kind have a "blog" now: From Beer and Bretzle vol 2

    ETC 2016 - ID
    ETC 2017 - WDG

    7,237 times read

Comments 29

  • LulleLurvas -

    Just wondering, since the substitute for a Hereditary spell for EOS is choosing a no. 1 spell of another path, how the spell selection works for EOS Adepts and Masters. For instance, could a EOS Wizard Adept choose the path of Pyromancy and pick Pyromancy 4 and then use its Hereditary feature to choose Divination 1, thus having a spell combination of 1 - 4 but from different paths?

  • Uthegen -

    great ideas and great work of bringing it together. Just from reading it feels more straight forward :)

    I realy like the easy approach for miscast - and the fact that the miscasts stays. (no master thesis required anymore to calculate MDU, Whichfire hits and strength etc..)

  • destroyem -

    Can you still dispel remains in play (oaken throne) spells as previously?

  • PadrePadre -

    Sounds very solid, I really like the mindset behind the design. Thanks devs!

  • Lowin Bayrod -

    Well, I for one welcome our new wizards overlords.
    Really dig the new rules, very well thought & balanced, congrats to the rules team.
    I was glad to have contributed a little among all other proposals and be a small part of this with everyone.

  • Worm -

    Great job, i also love the pictures.

    • tiny -

      he pitures are not new ... they are all from the full magic book including the background for magic and stuff ;)

  • Pofl -

    Very nice!

  • Tubz -

    May RNG(j)esus rest in piece. <3

  • ak1979 -

    I m impressed guys, great overhaul of the magic phase

  • Commodus Leitdorf -

    This is all real interesting. Thanks for your work guys

  • Ok@mi -

    I think the flux cards should have names instead of numbers. Something along the lines "rip", "tear", "mend" and such, showing the veil as a fabric between the realities. It makes remembering the effects easier as well, as you will have a direct vision of what is actually happening, deepens immersion and can be a great way of implementing art into the cards as it shows a vivid image of what is going on during the phase.

    • Kathal -

      Just saying, a hole in the Veil equals an exploding Atomic Bomb in that area. Not the best to use words like this in this regard ;)

    • Uthegen -

      nice idea, and would also add "background" to the veil "event". Like "low tide", or "overwhelming"..

    • Kathal -

      The background team is aware of this "request" (to say it this way), however, it will take some time to find proper names.

  • JackStreicher -

    Did you nerf druidism? (It is ridiculously strong in too many ways. Example: +3 T with oaken throne is a no brainer; Rather +1Base and +2 with OT etc.)

  • CrusaderPL -

    Looks Great!

  • Tofic -

    stable magic omnomnom <3

  • terryfl -

    No rolling dice for dwarfs, cheers for taking all the fun away

  • InToTheWannaB -

    looks great guys

  • kigraa -

    Less RNG !! i like it a lot ! <3 good work