Not a good argument. Historical vs Fantasy is aesthetic. His argument is simulationist vs gamist, as should yours be. You are right that more historical style games care about simulation over gameplay, but I don't think he's wrong to call for what he wants in this game. And frankly I agree with him.Sure. But I think the gameplay you are arguing for is never what this game has been.I think you are arguing for similar gameplay to what is found in historicals.Its not an argument I am making on basis of historical purism. Its an argument I am making on gameplay function.Ok. I disagree.I think you might find yourself better served by historicals.
So I was trying to save you some time and heartache by recommending you play historicals
To plagiarize Cato the Elder "And further WYSIWYG must be destroyed" facebook.com/FirebrandProductions/
Queen of Pants